Bloody Wrote:If you think PP is broken and needs to be banned, then the following list is broken and should be banned as well:
EDP
Asura
AD
Full Divest
Assump
Berserk
While we are at it, let's ban all trans classes from PVP altogether? You are talking about PP spamambility? Are you saying you can make a Creator/Alchie that can outheal an EDP'd Sinx? Well if you can, bring it on, I'd love to see you do that.
Where did I EVER say I wanted to make an alch class char who could out heal EDP. All you have to do is survive 1 hit and with pots you're pretty much set. If you sit there and take it you're going to die but if you run away and heal during the delay you're fine AND have time to attack. If you have your homunc attacking and you spam AD as soon as the SinX uncloaks (by sight or by attacking you) then any normal build IS GOING TO DIE. You won't even need to heal or use any pots. And that's exactly the point. If you're not up against a SinX or a Champ then you don't really have to worry about a potential 1HKO and with any number of pots AT ALL you WILL kill them before they kill you. Without pots you actually have a chance to lose because they CAN whittle your HP down.
Bloody Wrote:And I brought EDP up because you brought PP up. You try to ban a skill on one of my main classes, doesn't it make sense that I try the same to your only class? I don't see you asking for a limited number of PB bottles.
Kadar Wrote:Unlimited Buffing items, Unlimited green pots/panacea, Unlimited EDP/AD, Unlimited hide/cloak/chasewalk time.
Looks like you want unlimited of whatever makes you go on in a battle till you win. Is it just me or are you just a little too biased?
How about no? So if my main was a SN you would want to ban one of their skills? If my main was a Champ you would want asura banned? If I was a Sniper would you try and ban DS? And you call ME biased? You don't care a thing about pvp balance. You just want the odds to continue to be stacked in your favor. So no Bloody, it doesn't make any sense that you would try and limit my main class just because I see an issue with the balance in one of your skills. This discussion is about balance not what class a player uses.
and btw..
Unlimited buffing items helps all classes. Green pots/panacea helps all skill using classes. Unlimited EDP/AD because in the past those have been limited unjustly and I don't see anything game breaking about them. Unlimited hide/cloak/chasewalk benefits thief classes the most but also benefits anyone with frill and smokie.
Want to know what keeps me going in a battle until I win? SP RECOVERY ITEMS. SinX have low sp so we need to make the most of what we got. If my opinions were all about how to benefit myself wouldn't I want SP items to be allowed? Wouldn't I want links and other such things to be allowed? SinX is a class all about killing in as few hits as possible. So if others get healing items to spam I'm affected less because my goal is to kill them on the first hit anyway. It would actually be easier for me WITH healing items because SinX have two of the most effective escape skills (backslide and cloak) giving me ample time to heal.
So what's not adding up? Oh right.. this supposed bias I have. If I were biased there are so many nonsensical things I would be pushing for. This discussion isn't about you as a person or a player. It's about balancing event style pvp. So don't be a fool seeking petty vindication. Show me why Potion Pitcher is balanced in combination with all of the other Creator skills. Show me how a non SinX or Champ class can kill a smart Creator. Show me how if we had pots it wouldn't be a fancy Rock/Paper/Scissors match.